Canadian Underground Infrastructure Logo

Tendering the Environment

Hanlan Feedermain Contract 3 included significant changes to the tender document, removing the ability for bidders to overlook environmental requirements

Excavation begins for one of the watermain shafts along Tomken Road.
Excavation begins for one of the watermain shafts along Tomken Road.

Environmental concerns and mishaps have been the cause of many delays, cost overruns, shutdowns and legal implications over the years. Many people in the industry will read this and think that delays caused by environmental factors are a result of multiple, complicated or changing regulations. While these are sometimes contributing factors, the root of the problem starts with contract tenders, more specifically the way they are written or not written.

When it comes to contract tenders, the wording and often elusive nature of environmental factors results in a disconnect between the infrastructure construction industry and the associated project`s environmental considerations and requirements. Wording that surrounds environmental considerations on the job tender is vague at best, with no line items; line items are virtually non-existent on the bid form.

To take a step back, the purpose of a tender process is to be transparent in order to provide an equal opportunity for contractors to bid on a project. To create a fair process, some standard criteria must be met: everyone is provided with access to the same tender information; everyone has the same amount of time to plan and submit a proposal; everyone is evaluated using the same system, based on meeting the same criteria.

At the outset, all tenders meet the above standard requirements with the intent to create a level playing field for bidders.

The problem: Typical tender scenario

We all know, low bid gets the job. So if low bid gets the job, why would any person who wants to be awarded the job include “unnecessary” costs (i.e. environmental considerations) if the tender does not require it? Now fast forward to the lucky low bidder who got the job, who is now working to carry out the project and reality sets in. Since there were no line items required in the tender for environmental considerations, the contractor is now faced with dealing with who is in fact responsible – well the contractor of course. So what does this often mean? Extra costs, project delays and potential shutdowns.

So the contractor is now left with two options: Do it properly, which means they cover the cost of environmental components (ie environmental monitoring, erosion and sediment controls, fish removal and relocation, etc.) – not a very profitable option (which defeats the purpose of low bid wins); or continue with the project status quo and implement risk management, keeping fingers and toes crossed that the project does not come under public or regulatory scrutiny – “fly under the radar.”

Perhaps the best way to explain it is with the saying “Contractors are some of the most environmentally responsible people, so long as they are getting paid for their efforts.”

Due to the vague wording, direction and expectations as related to environmental considerations in tender documents, the illusion of the level playing field is replaced with the reality of extra costs, project delays, potential shutdowns and potential negative environmental effects and tarnished reputations. Until now.

Challenging the tender status quo

In 2013 the Municipality of Peel Region’s Water Capital Group opted to reflect on past experiences and make significant changes to a tender document on a very substantial feedermain project – Hanlan Feedermain Contract 3.

Significant onus was placed on the contractor within the tender with clear direction and expectations.

Allowances were placed in the specifications for the contractor to retain an environmental specialist, which completely removed the ability for bidders to overlook, and not cost for, environmental requirements.

What the Water Capital Group in Peel Region did differently

Examples of key requirements included in their tender:

1. Peel Region’s Water Capital Group made the qualifications of the required environmental consultant very clear:

“The Vendor shall retain the services of an environmental consultant, however, the environmental consultant will report to and will receive instructions from the Agency and the Engineer. Invoices from the environmental consultant will be processed by the Vendor and included in each payment certificate. The Agency will pay the Vendor for these charges and the Vendor shall immediately pass the payment on to the environmental consultant with no deduction, but subject to normal Contract holdback. The Vendor may apply a markup or management charge to the invoices from the environmental consultant, with such charge being no greater than 10 percent of the invoice amount…The environmental consultant shall have the proper designation(s) and/or certification(s) and experience in dewatering monitoring and control, employed by an organization operating under a Certificate of Authorization (COA) issued by the Association of Professional Geoscientists of Ontario (APGO), and they shall have, as a minimum qualified staff with recognized professional designations or certification in aquatic/fisheries, ecological and hydrogeological sciences.”

2. Requirements for submissions in the form of written plans/reports were explicitly detailed:

“Temporary control submittals – Environmental Management Plan, Dewatering and Monitoring Plan, ESC and surface water management plan, disposal of waste materials and haul routes plan.”

Timing and contents of these submissions were detailed in the tender and included as line items on the bid form.

Small change, big impact: Benefits of detailing environmental considerations in the tender

Peel Region’s Water Capital Group took the time to make the expectations clear and ensure that costs were accounted for. This removed the ambiguity from the tender process, resulting in a true level playing field for bidders – essentially creating a win-win scenario. In other words, low bidder wins, low bidder can complete the project carrying real costs, and the environment is no longer the afterthought.

The Water Capital Group’s decision to include detailed environmental requirements in their tenders is a huge leap forward. The hope is that other proponents will recognize the benefits and follow suit to include these considerations in their tenders. The industry has been moving in the direction of shifting liability to the contractor, but the fact remains that as the “owner,” liability can never be completely removed. The owner will be always be “the responsible party” and should therefore make its expectations clear, ensure that costs are accounted for, and remove the ambiguity.

Peel Hanlan Contract 3 may not be the only attempt at this unique model of clarity of direction and expectation, but it is certainly a leap forward.

The early stages of a shaft compound for watermain installation along Tomken Road.
Construction ready to go for the installation of the Mississauga City Centre Watermain along Eastgate Parkway.

More from Projects

Sanexen successfully finishes NYC tunnel repairs in record time

During the weekend of October 20th, Sanexen Water, Inc., a member of the LOGISTEC family, successfully completed major repairs in the Lincoln Tunnel in New York City with minimal impact. When the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) began planning repairs and upgrades to Route 495 and the Lincoln Tunnel, one of the requirements was to repair two cast iron cement-encased water main sections at each end of the tunnel that supply water for fire prevention.  Sanexen Water was selected for its unparalleled expertise and its innovative Aqua-Pipe trenchless technology, to repair these aging water mains while other construction work was in progress. New trenchless technology is used for the replacement or rehabilitation of existing underground infrastructure with minimal excavation and disruption to surface traffic. 

Final double breakthrough at the Emscher sewer

With the breakthrough of the last two tunnel boring machines into the target pit in Oberhausen-Biefang on June 12, 2017 the tunnel and pipe jacking work for the Emscher sewer has been completed. Over a period of 25 years numerous Herrenknecht tunnelling machines and a wide range of additional equipment were successfully used in the Europe-wide unique environmental and sewage project of Emschergenossenschaft.

Bulls Bridge Replacement Penstock

In the early 1900s, the New Milford Power Company successfully completed the first commercially viable hydroelectric power plant on the Housatonic River in Connecticut.  The project, Bulls Bridge Development, broke ground in spring 1902 and was in operation by 1903. Bulls Bridge was named after the Bull family that had lived in the area for generations. 

Herrenknecht tunnel borers continue success story in L.A.

Los Angeles is a vibrant center of international film art and innovation - not just on the surface. The area below ground is the scene of state-of-the-art engineering achievements. German high-tech machines from Herrenknecht are creating underground arteries for the American city. Tunnel boring machine (TBM) , Harriet successfully completed her drive for the Crenshaw/LAX Transit Project in April 2017. Angeli just finished digging the first of two tunnels for the Regional Connector Transit Corridor on July 18th. From spring 2018 onward the tunnel boring stars will have additional company: for each of the "Purple Line Extension Sections 1 + 2", two more Herrenknecht TBMs will be working their way through the difficult ground. All three projects are part of the strategic subway extension in L.A. to relieve the traffic above ground.

Mexico City’s Record-Breaking Crossover TBM makes Final Breakthrough

In June , a select group of project officials, including Mexico's President Enrique Peña Nieto, celebrated the final breakthrough of an epic tunneling project.  The 8.7 m (28.5 ft) diameter Robbins Crossover TBM is the first such hybrid machine to operate in North America, and it completed the Túnel Emisor Poniente (TEP) II on a high note.  The TBM, known an XRE—a Crossover (X) between Rock (R) and EPB (E) TBMs—navigated fault zones, variable ground, low cover, and more to achieve a national record of 57 m (187 ft) in one day as well as maximum rates of 231 m (758 ft) in one week and 702 m (2,303 ft) in one month. 

Speedy pipeline connection in Australia

In just three months Australian drilling contractor Dunstans Construction Group installed a 700-meter-long pipeline in Anglesea (Victoria). A 250 tonne HDD Rig from Herrenknecht played a key role in the achievement. Within a very short time the construction crew built a sea outfall with the machine, as well as pulling in the pipeline all the way back to the local water treatment plant.

Worksite injuries driving demand for composite manhole covers

Composite materials are in demand as industries are experiencing hazards and injuries when using traditional steel and other metal products. Reports of crushed and amputated fingers and toes along with burns, back injuries and other ailments have given industries ranging from data centres to water treatment plants a reason to seek safer alternatives. In the United States in 2014-15 there were 3,675 incidences of reported injuries within the manufacturing industry alone. Thirty-two percent of these incidences were reported as back injuries which led to a total of 125,880 missed working days. Composites are an ideal solution to these problems due to their lightweight yet durable properties. By using lighter materials, operational injuries are prevented, worksites are made safer, and ease of installation and maintenance is made available to utility workers and contractors.

Montreal-based consultancy completes inspection and leak detection of six 1,200-mm steel watermains and one 1,500-mm PCCP main in Montreal

Since September 2013, GAME Consultants has been paving the way for the next generation of watermain condition assessment tools by using existing tools and working to improve the results with every project. The company’s position is to equip itself with a wide range of tools designed exclusively for use in watermains.

Subscribe to our free newsletter

Get our newsletter

Learn more

A tale of two manhole fixes

Canadian contractors are cost effectively rehabilitating failing manholes and sewers without excavation or barrel replacement using the Permacast and CentriPipe systems developed by AP/M Permaform (AP/M) and distributed by Martech, Inc. Edmonton-based OSCO Mudjacking & Shotcreting Ltd. applied Permacast on two manhole projects with widely varying challenges:

  • A new 9-metre manhole installed as part of Edmonton’s massive project converting the QE II Highway and 41 Avenue SW connection to a grade-separated interchange.
  • Six failing manholes in remote Carmacks, a Yukon village.

Robbins achieves another breakthrough in Bangalore

On June 8, 2016, one of two 6.4 m (21.0 ft) diameter mixed-face EPB machines broke through at Namma Metro. After being launched in March 2015, the TBM named Kaveri made its way through its difficult 750 meter (2,460 ft.) drive from Chickpet to Majestic. Sister machine Krishna, launched in December 2015 is not far behind, and is expected to break through in approximately two months.

Completion of trackwork for the Toronto-York Spadina Subway extension

A special event was held to celebrate the completion of trackwork in the new Toronto-York Spadina Subway Extension (TYSSE) tunnels and stations where a total of 17.4 kilometres of track and four sections of special track have been installed. Dignitaries walked down into the station to track level where they participated in a ceremonial tapping in of the last clips that hold the rails in place.

Pipe change at Prince Edward Island watermain expansion project

As a PVC-friendly city, Summerside, Prince Edward Island planned to use PVC pipe as it began Phase II of its Pope Road watermain expansion project. The project required 300 metres of 400-mm (16-inch) pipe, and was taking place in an area of the city with no existing water line.

Waterloo biofilm battle

In Canada, the quality of drinking water that flows from the taps of most households is for the most part taken for granted. While the country has pockets of populations with water quality concerns, Canadians generally regard their drinking water not only as safe, but of a higher quality than other developed nations.

Innovative approach to sanitary sewer cleaning

Civil engineers could be looking at London as a template for hard-to-access sewer cleaning jobs. The Ontario municipality recently installed three specialized manholes with sealed access flanges into one of its longest and oldest sewers in order to clean the pipe, after a camera probe two years ago identified it as being partially filled with solids and grit that would eventually restrict flows.

Turbidity problem addressed

In Dieppe, New Brunswick, complaints about the quality of drinking water running through a decades-old water main had city engineers scratching their heads for a solution that wouldn’t create too much disruption for residents.

Robbins EPB Begins Light Rail Link

Tucked away on a small jobsite in a quiet neighbourhood bordering a busy interstate highway, a Robbins Earth Pressure Balance (EPB) machine underwent Onsite First Time Assembly (OFTA). The OFTA method allows for TBMs to be assembled onsite, and results in time and cost savings to the contractor. On November 17, 2014 unbeknownst to commuters driving by, the 6.65-metre (21.8 feet) TBM rumbled to life and began its journey south into the city of Seattle, Washington.

Subscribe to our free magazine

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more

Concrete Conduit Challenges Pipe-Bursting Contractor

One of the most effective ways of replacing a pipe using trenchless technology is pipe bursting, which replaces a traditional construction trench with launching and receiving pits that pull the new pipe through the existing one, breaking the old pipe into fragments that stay in the ground in-situ.

Breaking Through to Billy Bishop

It is only 120 metres across the Western Gap of Toronto Harbour from the Toronto waterfront to the Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (BBTCA) but it still requires a ferry boat ride for passengers going to and returning from the airport on Toronto Island. The ever-increasing popularity of this airport with close proximity to downtown Toronto has pushed the ferry capacity to its limits.

CUC crews endure extreme conditions to complete Air Liquide project

Working in underground construction, it’s common for utility contractors to encounter unexpected challenges. In fact, it’s those challenges that often test a company’s mettle, its expertise and its people. A successful outcome not only brings a sense of pride to those who were involved in the project, but can often cement a relationship with a customer that is both long-lasting and fruitful.

Revitalizing Toronto’s waterfront roads

Downtown Toronto benefits greatly from the natural beauty of Lake Ontario providing it with a stunning waterfront that attracts tourists and local residents on a daily basis. Combining traffic, transit, tourists and other factors in an area that was designed and developed many years ago has caused a call for revitalization along parts of the city’s waterfront.