Canadian Underground Infrastructure Logo

Study Finds Land Disposal of HDD Mud a Viable Option

Application of HDD mud to research plots.
Application of HDD mud to research plots.

Company info

1959 W. Fir Ave.
P.O. Box 66
Perry, OK
US, 73077-0066

Website:
ditchwitch.com

Read more

113 Student Union
Stillwater, OK
US, 74078

Website:
okstate.edu

Read more

For horizontal directional drilling (HDD) contractors, an important concern at the jobsite is how to deal with the drilling mud that is sent down the bore hole and recirculated back to the surface.

While HDD contractors sometimes employ mud reclaimers to recycle mud during the boring process, more often the mud is used just once, before being gathered up with a vacuum truck and dumped, usually on the jobsite, on the contractor’s property or at a municipal landfill facility.

Expensive to dump

Contractors that go the landfill route will quickly find their expenses mounting, with tipping fees ranging from $25 to $50 a ton, or $0.50 a gallon. Considering that some drilling contractors might need to dump up to 20,000 gallons a week, the cost of HDD mud disposal is clearly a major concern. These costs are passed on to the municipality, pushing the burden beyond the contractor to the ratepayer. As the HDD industry continues to grow, more and more mud is being generated that needs to be dealt with. Putting all these factors together, the desire for the industry to develop an effective, cost-efficient means to dispose of HDD drilling mud has become a high priority.

It was with these concerns in mind that Ditch Witch, a large manufacturer of HDD drilling equipment, approached Oklahoma State University (OSU) with the idea of conducting a series of experiments with HDD mud. Ditch Witch and OSU wanted to find out whether the ingredients in HDD mud were harmful to the environment, and in what quantities the mud might be limiting to forage yield and seed germination.

Putting HDD mud under the microscope

Typical HDD mud consists of water and soil from the borehole, along with additives that are mixed in to facilitate the drilling process. Bentonite clay, for example, is often added to increase fluid viscosity during the drilling process, but the residual material can improve the ability of the soil to retain nutrients after it is land applied. Polymers such as polyacrylamide are used for the same purpose. Soda ash is added to control pH and surfactants are used to prevent heavy clays from balling up at the drill bit.

In the first experiment, Ditch Witch collected 56 samples of HDD mud taken from 28 states. The samples were sent to OSU, which conducted a series of tests on them, including their levels of pH, salts, plant nutrients and heavy metals. While seven samples did have concentrations of heavy metals beyond those found in normal soils, the levels were well below those mandated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for the land application of exceptional quality biosolids under Part 503 ruling, and thus safe for land application.

The rest of the samples had heavy metal concentrations within normal levels found in typical soils.

“As far as we know, there is no chemical present beyond allowable concentrations that can limit the land application of spent HDD mud as a means of disposal,” states an abstract of the study, titled “Can Urban Horizontal Directional Drilling Mud be Land Applied?” “Based on the study, it is highly unlikely that excessive trace metals will be applied to soils through land application of the residuals.”

While the study found that ingredients in drilling mud in the vast majority of samples present no harmful effects on the environment, it is important to recognize that all HDD mud isn’t appropriate for use as a pure potting soil. For example, using pure mud on its own to grow vegetables may not be safe. However, the researchers found the mud can be added as a soil amendment, for example, to grow hay or for grazing cattle.

“Adding it to an agricultural field in a uniform manner, either for cattle grazing or hay or some other agricultural activity, or in a bare plot soil situation as might be found on a construction site, didn’t show any negative indication in terms of its effects on that soil or the plant material that was there,” said Kelvin Self, research and development project manager for Ditch Witch, who spoke to CUI about the results of the study.

“What was most pleasing about it, from the industry standpoint and my own personal standpoint, is that we really didn't find anything of great concern,” said Self, an industry veteran with a doctorate in agricultural engineering. “A hundred percent of the samples, according to OSU, could be land-disposed quite safely. So that was a very nice result.”

Test contaminated soils

The good news for the industry, however, comes with a caveat. While most HDD mud is basically benign, contractors must be aware of where they’re drilling before they consider land-disposing their mud. If the contractor is drilling in an area that was historically contaminated, say where mining or oilfield activity took place, the HDD mud should be tested prior to disposal.

“They have to have some knowledge of the area they’re drilling through. Because if they suspect at all that there could be high concentrations of metals back down in those soils, then they’re going to have the same concentrations in their mud. In which case, they need to test it,” said Chad Penn, associate professor at OSU, who led the study along with graduate student Josh Daniel.

How much mud?

Assuming that isn’t the case, and the area being drilled through is uncontaminated, the next question becomes: if the HDD mud is spread over land, how much of it is appropriate for the mud to become a good host for plants, and when does it become limiting?

Ditch Witch and OSU sought to find out by conducting two experiments. In the first experiment, normal HDD mud gathered from a local contractor was sprayed as a slurry on a typical field of Bermudagrass hay. The second experiment spread the HDD mud over plots of bare ground, sprinkled with Bermudagrass seed. This experiment was meant to simulate a construction site where HDD mud would likely be applied in a realworld situation.

After four months, plots that received the HDD mud on the hayfield, at rates equivalent to 10-, 20-, 30, 40- and 50- tons of dry solid per acre, produced the same amount of grass as control plots that did not receive any HDD mud. Plots that received the HDD mud could handle up to 50 tons per acre without any negative impact on grass production.

For the bare ground plots, the same rates of HDD mud were applied. After 60 days, researchers found plots that had received 10 tons of solids per acre produced significantly more grass than a control plot and the other rates. Plots that received 20, 30 and 40 tons per acre produced the same amount of grass as the control, while plots receiving the heaviest rate of 50 tons per acre produced slightly less.

The results indicated that when HDD mud is applied on existing grass cover, grass growth was not significantly affected by the amount of mud applied up to 50 tons per acre. On bare ground, however, applying too much HDD mud – 50 tons per acre or more – will impede plant growth.

If all of this sounds academic, Self has come up with a formula that contractors can use to determine how much HDD mud they should apply to a field – assuming that land application is permitted in their jurisdiction, and they have determined that the area in which they have drilled is not known to be contaminated.

The first step is to pick the tons per acre at which to apply the material. Next, measure the mud density using a mud balance. Then, plug the mud density into an equation, to get the number of gallons per acre of mud residue needed to get the desired application rate.

For example, to get 40 tons of solid material per acre, with a mud density of 12.3 pounds per gallon, a contractor would need to apply 12,500 gallons of mud residue. From there, in order to apply the material uniformly across an acre of land, at a width of 10 feet per row, the contractor would apply 600 gallons of mud per row.

Minimal regulation likely required

CUI asked Self, from Ditch Witch, and Penn, from OSU, what the likelihood is of land application becoming standard practice in the industry, and achieving widespread acceptance among the general public. Both acknowledged that there is a role for regulators to play in determining whether the mud needs to be tested before being land-applied, and not leaving it up completely to a contractors’ discretion.

Self, however, said there is definitely a risk of over-regulation.

“Of the 56 samples we took, all 56 of them would be safe to apply. That doesn’t mean that if you took a 57th one, that you wouldn’t find something. It just means that there’s pretty strong evidence that we’re sort of rubbing our hands together for no real reason,” he said.

“I would say the challenge is determining how to regulate it without putting these guys out of business,” said Penn, noting the cost to the contractor of testing each soil batch.

Oklahoma State will be publishing the results of its experiments on HDD mud into peer-reviewed scientific journals. Self said those papers should be coming out towards the end of this year and, when they do, could form the basis of a body of research that helps determine to what extent the disposal of HDD mud will be regulated. Self indicated that interested readers are invited to email [email protected] referencing the “HDD Mud Disposal Research Info” to receive the latest information available.

For now, he said the evidence suggests that minimal regulation is required. “The bottom line here is what we found is that the mud basically reflects what’s in the soil that’s already there. What you’re drilling through is just normal soils near the surface and the mud reflects what’s in those soils.”

Further information on this topic, along with recommendations, is presented by OSU cooperative extension at: http://pods. dasnr.okstate.edu/docushare/dsweb/Get/ Document-9597/PSS-2916web.pdf

Scraped/bare soil plots pictured immediately after surface application (top) and approximately 120 days after application (bottom).

More from Horizontal Directional Drilling

Quanta Services sets new HDD operators up for success through valuable training

The rise in underground utility projects is good news for contractors across the country. However, whether it be due to fiber build-out or aging infrastructure replacement, this growth requires underground utility contractors to find and employ more horizontal directional drill (HDD) operators. This demand has resulted in a shortage of qualified, skilled and confident operators in the underground construction industry.

Vermeer's new Navigator horizontal directional drill designed to deliver in rocky, congested environments

The new Vermeer D23x30DR S3 Navigator horizontal directional drill (HDD) integrates dual-rod technology into a compact machine design to efficiently maneuver through rock in congested cities, busy neighborhoods or tight jobsites. Featuring a class-leading narrow footprint and a weight of 16,500 pounds (7,484 kg), the D23x30DR S3 is the lightest rock drill on the market and is well suited for fibre, electrical, gas and water installation in hard rock, as well as other challenging ground conditions.

HDD virtual reality simulator developed by Ditch Witch to improve training and safety

More than 50 percent of reported underground utility damages are the result of insufficient excavation practices according to the 2017 DIRT Report. The Ditch Witch organization, a Charles Machine Works Company, has introduced an industry-first Virtual Reality (VR) Simulator to better prepare horizontal directional drill (HDD) operators for safe underground construction through cutting-edge training technology. 

Ditch Witch updates fluid management systems to improve HDD productivity

The Ditch Witch organization, a Charles Machine Works Company, has updated its line of fluid management systems to increase productivity and reduce costs on horizontal directional drilling (HDD) jobsites. These advanced models incorporate new design features to meet the highest standards for jobsite productivity, improved drilling fluid flow, increased durability, and faster mixing cycles and yield times.

Subscribe to our free newsletter

Get our newsletter

Learn more

Radius HDD Over-Bit Reamer

Designed and tested with the help of small bore contractors, the Radius HDD Over-Bit Reamer easily attaches to an existing rock bit without breaking a single connection. The Radius Over-Bit Reamer only needs 16 inches of clearance. With the pilot tool still attached, the sonde can be used to track progress through tight easements during pullback. The Radius Over-Bit Reamer is available in 6- and 8-inch sizes with a variety of cutting styles.

Vermeer and Mincon form distribution alliance for rock tools

Two of the horizontal directional drilling (HDD) industry's leading equipment and tooling manufacturers, Vermeer Corporation and Mincon Group PLC, have formed a distribution alliance to expand contractors' access to quality rock tooling worldwide. As part of the agreement, Vermeer dealers are now the exclusive channel for Mincon HDD air hammer systems, HDD pull reaming hammers and HDD support equipment, including HDD support stations and oilers.

Vermeer D8x12 HDD provides compact productivity

Vermeer expands its line of utility installation equipment with the launch of the D8x12 Navigator horizontal directional drill. This new compact and highly productive drill is sized for working in tight spaces, features straightforward controls and delivers quiet operation. With two drill rod options for added versatility, the Vermeer D8x12 is well suited for small service installations, including gas distribution, power, water and telecommunication networks.

Online parts lookup tool aids Ditch Witch customers

The Ditch Witch organization, a Charles Machine Works Company, has released an advanced version of their industry-first, web-based tool that helps customers be more efficient and reduce downtime by quickly finding the service parts they need. The Ditch Witch Parts Lookup gives customers easy access to detailed parts information and a direct line of communication to dealerships for part verification and pick-list creation.

Miami Beach HDD installation recognized as Plastic Pipe Institute's Project of the Year

The longest horizontal directional drilled (HDD) installation of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) pipe in the United States and Canada was recognized as Project of the Year by the Plastics Pipe Institute, Inc. (PPI). The award was presented to PPI member company ISCO Industries at the association's annual membership meeting in May 2017. PPI is the major North American trade association representing all segments of the plastic pipe industry,

Pit-launched mini directional drill

TT Technologies' redesigned Grundopit pit-launched mini directional drill is well suited for difficult fiber-to-the-home and utility service line installations in tight working conditions. The unit is compact, 54 inches long, 43 inches wide and 57 inches tall. The Grundopit delivers 13,489 lbs. of thrust and pull back and 553 ft. lbs. of torque with bore length up to 150 feet. The Grundopit is an ideal entry-level system for utilities, cable industries or as a supplement to larger units.

Robust fluid cleaning system offers small footprint and quiet operation

Pipeline and utility contractors attending the 2017 International Utility and Construction Equipment Exposition (ICUEE) in Louisville, Kentucky, were first to see the newly released American Augers M-300D HDD fluid cleaning system. Based on American Augers' successful, highly portable M-200 platform, the M-300 system's small trailer size lowers registration and excise tax requirements while supporting any make of 60- to 100-ton drill unit with a true 300 gpm fluid-cleaning capability. 

Subscribe to our free magazine

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more

HammerHead Trenchless launches remote-controlled 22-ton winch at ICUEE

HammerHead Trenchless, a Charles Machine Works company, introduced its new 22-ton, radio remote-controlled HydroGuide® HG2200 cable winch at the 2017 International Construction and Utility Equipment Exposition (ICUEE) in Louisville, Kentucky. The HG2200 completes the HammerHead line of next-generation winches designed for maximum efficiency and ease-of-use in pipe-bursting, slip-lining and pipe-slitting applications.

Ditch Witch offers next generation AT40 all terrain directional drill optimizes downhole performance in hard rock

To enhance utility contractors' efficiency while drilling and steering in hard rock, Ditch Witch, a Charles Machine Works Company, has released the new AT40 All Terrain horizontal directional drill (HDD). The machine features an advanced, two-pipe All Terrain drilling system that provides 33 percent more torque than competitive units.  The newly optimized All Terrain drilling system includes multiple patent-pending designs that improve downhole operation. An inner-rod design provides a flush system that improves tool-joint durability and steering in hard rock conditions. To further improve steering and optimize fluid flow, a reliable All Terrain connection reduces the risk of collar damage. 

DITCH WITCH unveils enhanced, next generation underground construction equipment, parts and technology at ICUEE

The Ditch Witch organization, a Charles Machine Works company, is planning to unveil a wide variety of new and enhanced underground construction equipment, parts, tools, and technology—all designed to boost productivity at the International Construction and Utility Equipment Exposition (ICUEE) Oct. 3-5 in Louisville, Kentucky. 

Major upgrade for HDD hammer system

The spring 2017 acquisition of Armadrillco solidified StraightLine HDD's position as a leader in hard condition tooling. The announcement today of the adaption of the patented Armadrillco transmitter housing to the RockEye Hammer System is a significant step in diffusing Armadrillco technology throughout StraightLine HDD tooling platforms.

Keys to a smooth running HDD operation

Success in the HDD business is about more than boring a stable hole and completing a successful pullback. It's about running your entire HDD operation like a well-oiled machine. Here are five ways we've seen successful HDD companies make businesses function more smoothly and create lasting success, followed by an example of what to look for in on specific type of tool, the backreamer. 

Performix Mixer Upgrade Announced

StraightLine HDD, Inc. announced the implementation of an upgrade to its popular Performix Mud Mix System. At the heart of the Performix System is the centrifugal pump, which generates the best laminar flow in the industry. The performance pump now features an upgraded silicon-carbide shaft seal. Compared to traditional ceramic seals, the new seal represents a considerable advancement in resiliency when subjected to the highly abrasive elements present in mud mixing. In field testing, silicon carbide seals improve service life by a factor of three,over ceramic seals.

Vermeer Introduces Silver Series Drill Rod

Vermeer has bolstered its  line of HDD tooling and accessories with the addition of the Silver Series drill rod. Building on the tradition of it's acclaimed Firestick drill rod, Silver Series drill rod gives contractors a quality aftermarket drill rod at an economic price.

Subscribe to our free newsletter

Get our newsletter

Learn more

Ditch Witch Launches JT10 HDD Rig

Ditch Witch has introduced the JT10 horizontal directional drill (HDD) providing operators with exceptional power in a compact, reliable platform. For superior productivity, the machine incorporates advanced features found on larger units while remaining the most compact drill in its class.

Ditch Witch boosts drill power with JT60 and JT60 all-terrain HDD Tier 4 upgrades

Today’s horizontal directional drilling (HDD) operators face plenty of challenges on large installation projects, including difficult terrain and tough soil conditions. To provide operators with the power and performance to conquer any job, Ditch Witch has introduced Tier 4 emission standard upgrades to the JT60 and JT60 All Terrain directional drills.

Extend your mud recycler’s lifespan

Equipment maintenance is a topic that no contractor particularly wants to address, but in light of the ever growing need to maximize production and cut down time it is extremely important. Your equipment will only continue to work properly if you take the time to perform simple routine maintenance.

Cross bore problem in the crosshairs

They are two words no contractor or municipal engineer wants to hear: cross bore. A cross bore is what happens when one underground utility intersects another. Most worrying is when a gas line punches through a sewer main or lateral. Cross bore risk has risen with the use of trenchless technologies like horizontal directional drilling, because the operator can’t physically see what’s in the immediate vicinity of the drill bit.

Subscribe to our free magazine

Get Our Magazine

Paper or Digital delivered monthly to you

Subscribe or Renew Learn more